From Chef To Chef’s

Homemade Chocolate Uncrustable | The Worktop

Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. See my Disclosure Policy for more information.

This chocolate uncrustable is better than store bought! We use the best chocolate spread. As such, it makes a perfect homemade uncrustable. It’s delicious and healthy for breakfast.

Uncrustables with chocolate almond butter

Homemade Chocolate Uncrustable is perfect for breakfast

I recently bought an uncrustable maker. And the kids love it!

An uncrustable maker magically transforms boring sandwiches into special treats. What used to be just a sandwich now becomes a moon. Or it becomes a round sled. Even more, a sandwich can become a trampoline!

I don’t usually encourage playing with food. However, this is an exception for good reason.

An uncrustable maker seals the sandwich together very nicely. Therefore, the fillings never fall out while the kids eat (or play). No sticky fingers!

We’ve tried a lot of different fillings since buying our uncrustable maker. In our experience, you can easily go sweet or savory.

One of our favorites is homemade chocolate uncrustable. So that’s why I’m sharing the recipe today! Hopefully you and your family will love this too.

Chocolate uncrustables on a plate - homemade

What chocolate spread to use for uncrustables?

This is the most important question when making a chocolate uncrustable!

If you are making a copy cat chocolate uncrustable, I would suggest you use Nutella. Smucker’s Uncrustables, the kind you buy at the store, uses a chocolate hazelnut spread.

However, I have found a chocolate spread that I think is even more delicious. Plus, it’s way healthier.

Barney Butter makes a delicious Almond Butter with Chocolate. We love it! It’s super smooth. And it has just the right amount of sweetness.

Personally, after trying several different chocolate spreads, this is my favorite. Compared to Nutella, Barney Butter chocolate spread wins. It’s so good and great for eating at breakfast.

One reason is that it’s smooth and easy to spread. Plus, there’s only 2g of added sugar per serving. That’s compared to 21g of added sugar in each serving of Nutella!

It’s the perfect spread for making chocolate uncrustables!

Using a sandwich cutter and sealer

How to use an uncrustable maker

Using the cool maker is the most fun part of making homemade uncrustables!

Which uncrustable maker is best?

There are a lot of different uncrustable makers on Amazon. It took me a while to find one I love.

This is the one I use. And I think it works great!

The one I have makes the classic Smucker’s Uncrustables edge shape. Some of the other sandwich sealers end up giving the sandwich a wavy edge. Not good if your kids are picky or extra observant.

Simple two step process

Using the uncrustable maker takes 2 steps. With your prepared sandwich, first you use the plain circle cutter to cut off the crust. Second, you push the sealer mould down to make the perfect sealed edge.

Voila! Your homemade uncrustable is done!

how to use an uncrustable maker

Tips for this homemade chocolate uncrustable recipe

This is a very simple recipe. But here are a few tips below. My goal is to help you make the best homemade uncrustable ever.

Use a soft bread

Using a soft bread will make the best uncrustables. That’s because the bread will not split or crack when you use the circle cutter and sealer.

I have good success using Wonder Bread or Nature’s Own Honey Wheat. Other sandwich sliced breads will likely work fine too.

While we usually eat whole wheat breads, they don’t work well for homemade uncrustables. Unfortunately, the texture of such loaves don’t hold up with the sandwich cutter. Instead, the uncrustable will often crack open.

Don’t use too much spread

It’s surprising how easily the filling of an uncrustable will overflow. As such, when you make your sandwich, don’t layer on too much spread.

Take a look at the photo below. See how some of the chocolate spread is on the sealed edge?

That brings me to the third tip.

homemade uncrustables with chocolate and almond butter

Keep the filing in the center

There’s no need to spread your filling all the way around the sandwich bread. Therefore, try to keep the filling in the center of the sandwich. By doing so, the spread won’t ooze out when you try to cut and seal the sandwich.

Enjoy this delicious chocolate uncrustable

I really hope you enjoy this recipe. While it’s super simple, hopefully these tips and recs will help. Now you can make your own healthier version of chocolate uncrustable too!

Don’t forget to grab a jar of Barney Almond Butter with Chocolate! In case you are wondering, this post isn’t sponsored. We just love it!

Want more uncrustables? Here’s our recipe for Peanut Butter and Honey Uncrustables.

Looking for more recipes? Don’t miss these kid-friendly breakfast ideas!

Lastly, here are a few recipes that would also work great with the almond butter with chocolate:

Homemade Chocolate Uncrustables -  Text Learn the Tricks
Chocolate uncrustables on a plate - homemade

Chocolate Uncrustables – Homemade Version

Print Recipe
Save Recipe

Serves: 1

This chocolate uncrustable is easy to make at home! Find out which spread to use to make this homemade uncrustable healthier than store bought.


  • Spread the almond butter with chocolate on one slice of the bread. Add the other slice on top and make a sandwich.

  • Using the uncrustable maker, cut out a circle. Do not remove the sandwich from the circle cutter.

  • Using the uncrustable sealer, press down inside the circle cutter to seal the sandwich.

  • Enjoy!

Course: Breads and Muffins, Breakfast

Cuisine: American

Keyword: Chocolate Uncrustables

Special Diet: Dairy Free, Vegan, Vegetarian

Cal : 163kcal

Note: Nutrition information is a rough estimate.

Love this?I would appreciate a star review! Snap a picture and share it with me on Instagram using #theworktop and tagging me @theworktop.

Rate this post

Need to check our Shop? Check best places for that. Choose only with one you wanna be!